NNYPainting

How do I choose paint colors that go together?

Short answer

Start from something that won't change, like flooring, countertops, brick, a rug or roof color, and pull colors from it. Build a palette of one main color, one supporting color and one accent, keep the undertones consistent (all warm or all cool), and test large samples on the wall in morning and evening light before you commit.

A simple method

  • Pick your fixed element and note whether it leans warm (yellow, red, orange) or cool (blue, green, gray).
  • Choose a main wall color with the same undertone.
  • Pick trim that contrasts in lightness, usually a white or a deep tone.
  • Add one accent from the color wheel: a neighbor (analogous) for calm, or an opposite (complementary) for energy.
  • Keep the whole-house flow in mind so adjoining rooms don't clash.

Test before you buy gallons

Paint 2 foot square samples or use peel-and-stick sample sheets, and look at them at different times of day. North-facing rooms make colors look cooler and darker. South-facing rooms warm them up.

Updated September 2026. Always follow the directions on your product's label; manufacturer instructions come first.